Like many of you, I have wondered for a long while now why this anime attracts troons so much. One could simply say "its gay and about little girls so of course troons like it", but if this were the case Prisma Ilya would be more popular among troons.L

Name
Options	Spoiler Image
Comment
File
Embed
Password	(For file deletion.)

File: 1688135971516-0.png (20.79 KB, 775x962, 1688133695303.png)ImgOps

File: 1688135971516-1.png (2.08 MB, 1920x1080, Screenshot_2023-06-14_23-2….png)ImgOps

PUELLA MAGI MADOKA MAGICA (grammatically correct spelling: puellae magi madoka magica) Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 14:39:31 №36722

Like many of you, I have wondered for a long while now why this anime attracts troons so much.
One could simply say "its gay and about little girls so of course troons like it", but if this were the case Prisma Ilya would be more popular among troons.
Let us consider romcoms, the main focusgroupp of these shows are insecure, pathetic boys, and so their main characters are likewise complete pussies.
In order for a show to successfully pander to a focusgroup there must be a point of identification for that target audience, but trannies clearly do not identify with women in general even if they want to.
I think analyzing Puella Magi Madoka Magica will present us with a view into the mind of tranny.

Many a pseudointellectual trannylover will sing the praises of PMMM's themes when there are none.
The only consistent theme is melodrama; characters willingly self destruct for the sake of "emotional" scenes, and their emotions are quite flippant. Sayaka self destruct in about three episodes and to a normal viewer, her metamorphosis from a cheerful girl into an angry and depressed mess may seem rushed and underdeveloped.
However, to the BPD-riddles troon, who cannot help but self-destruct, this server as point of identification. Sayaka's cute exterior (troon superego), monologues (troon ego) and emotion/behaviors (troon id) work in tandem to create the ultimate tranny self-insert.
Note that every single character in the show has these behaviours/emotions at some point in the show, but Sayaka is the worst offender by far.

The only other theme prevalent to any extent in PMMM is certain dooom. Up until the very last episode every character is doomed to die/ become a witch and big sad ensues.
It should be self-explanatory as to why der troon can identify with this, he may have deceived himself into thinking he is a woman, his physical body remains in revolt against the surgeries and hormones, and the troon subconsciously knows that he is doomed to die as a result of his troon behaviours.

Thank you for coming to my ted talk, if you have any questions/comments i will adress them.

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 14:43:54 №36723

Still best chadime of 2010s thoughever

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 14:46:32 №36724

File: 1688136392004.jpg (66 KB, 1080x1080, eren laugh.jpg)ImgOps

>>36723
...But enough about ShingeKINO Kyojin.
We're discussing miduka midgika.

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 14:47:56 №36725

File: 1688136475646.png (4.58 MB, 2082x1548, ClipboardImage.png)ImgOps

>...But enough about ShingeKINO Kyojin.
>We're discussing miduka midgika.

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 15:15:45 №36727

>>36725
>Displaying human emotions is bad now
Go back to your patrick bateman sigma grindset videos hoe nigga

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 17:05:06 №36737

>>36727
Eren lost. Seethe

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 17:05:47 №36738

>>36737
Even doe eron won

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 17:06:38 №36739

>>36738
Nope he lost

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 17:15:08 №36740

>>36738
>>36737
>>36727
>>36724
>>36725
>madoka thread
>shitkeki no cucking mutts posting garbage

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 17:21:20 №36741

>>36740
I'm gonna keep it a stack witchu, overrated mid + moeshit

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 17:22:57 №36742

>>36741
i dont even disagree

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 18:56:40 №36749

>>36722
didn’t read I’m really sorry

Chud 06/30/23 (Fri) 21:56:56 №36765

File: 1688162216621.jpg (339.44 KB, 738x733, 1386792467377.jpg)ImgOps

>>36722
Nah man, it really is as simple as "its gay and about little girls so of course troons like it". It's all Homura's fault. She is the yuri equivalent of the Ryo/Kaworu clone.

Chud 07/01/23 (Sat) 21:27:08 №36833

>>36765
sayaka is worse though
and kaworu was less of a little bitch than 'mura

Chud 07/01/23 (Sat) 23:05:52 №36836

True

Chud 07/08/23 (Sat) 22:24:13 №37414

https://youtu.be/TrgxHDoe8gA

Chud 08/01/23 (Tue) 05:21:22 №38795

>>36739
>Eren lost even doe billions died

Chud 08/02/23 (Wed) 10:03:34 №38884

>>36722
Good write-up, I think you are onto something.
>Sayaka self destruct in about three episodes and to a normal viewer, her metamorphosis from a cheerful girl into an angry and depressed mess may seem rushed and underdeveloped.
I'm not a tranny and I find Sayaka well written, no wonder she gets depressed when she knows she not only has to risk her life fighting monsters and will likely get eaten by one in 2 years max but also didn't even get the thing she wanted to when she made the wish, and that's not counting the other factors.
>their emotions are quite flippant
That's a plot point, incubators specifically seek emotional teenage girls.

I'm interested in your opinion on Rebellion since it's a rather controversial in fans eyes. The part where adult in teenage body witch protagonist manages to take Madoka out of her cosmic duty with AI YO seems likes something a tranny fan would enjoy though.

And gacha is uoooh 14yo belly eroi.

Chud 08/02/23 (Wed) 10:06:09 №38885

Madoka is popular with everyone because it's a good show.

Chud 08/02/23 (Wed) 10:47:08 №38886

>>38884
>I'm interested in your opinion on Rebellion since it's a rather controversial in fans eyes. The part where adult in teenage body witch protagonist manages to take Madoka out of her cosmic duty with AI YO seems likes something a tranny fan would enjoy though.
I havent wathed it yet, but i'll make another reviewpost once i do in this thread.

>I'm not a tranny and I find Sayaka well written, no wonder she gets depressed when she knows she not only has to risk her life fighting monsters and will likely get eaten by one in 2 years max but also didn't even get the thing she wanted to when she made the wish, and that's not counting the other factors.
the problem isnt the cause of her downward spiral, its the pacing. Problems eat at people for a while before they break, and i think PMMM would have benefited from 12 more episodes to space out the action and a less significant B plot.
The mental anguish is nearly always the main focus until the walpurgisnacht. I think it'd work better as a B plot thing.
It should have been treated as the Hitchcockian bomb

Chud 08/02/23 (Wed) 11:00:26 №38887

Didn't read a single word, she does beat Goku though

Chud 08/02/23 (Wed) 12:28:21 №38895

File: 1690979301798.jpg (267.52 KB, 1366x759, 1673730154807124.jpg)ImgOps

>>38887
No, Madoka greatest feat before she becomes Madokami is one-shotting a city-tier witch and after that she only goes after witches and since Goku isn't a witch, he is outside the sphere of her powers.
If we count Kriemhild Gretchen then the later forms could make a problem because they are Infinite Zamasu-tier of bullshit.
SNITCHku could just call Zeno though.
Pic loosely related

Chud 08/02/23 (Wed) 12:37:00 №38896

>>38895
>SNITCHku could just call Zeno
He doesn't have the button anymore, not that it matters since peak Madoka is infinitely more powerful than Zeno either way.

Chud 08/02/23 (Wed) 17:16:35 №38912

>>38896
>peak Madoka is infinitely more powerful than Zeno either way.
Madoka can't do anything to Zenos because they aren't witches and Zenos can't do anything to Madoka because she exists beyond time (Zenos don't).
They can nuke the universe absorbed by witch Madoka althoughever.

Chud 08/02/23 (Wed) 17:19:03 №38913

File: 1690996743363.gif (1021.64 KB, 1400x1406, 1.gif)ImgOps

>Hitchcockian bomb

Chud 08/08/23 (Tue) 20:55:24 №39554

>>38884
I watched rebellion, and the two recap movies, and liked it.

I also caught something i missed initially; kyubey canonicaally fucked all the megucas
homura refers to kyubey as "incubator", a male succubus that rapes women
And transforming into a magical girl is a metaphor for growing up in magical girls shows
also, all megucas get a egg-shaped soul thing (a fertility metaphor) after kyubey has incubated them
this has made me rethink my opinion on sayaka's arc, the reason that she wouldnt pursue that violin twink despite the grief it caused her, was that she was raped by kyubey, and had lost her innocence
kyubey also turns them into lifeless dolls, they're literally turned into his sexdolls
when the megucas are used up by kyubey (due to his manipulation and rape of them) they turn into despairing witches, much like irl harpies that once were cock-caroussel-riding stacies
its essentially a metaphor for child sexual abuse, and kyubey represents the manipulative peadophile

Chud 08/09/23 (Wed) 05:28:06 №39586

>>38912
>faggot doesn't use standard battle assumptions

Chud 08/09/23 (Wed) 15:07:41 №39601

>>39554
>homura refers to kyubey as "incubator", a male succubus that rapes women
That's incubus, incubator is the place where you put premie babie
But yes, it is metaphor for innocence loss.

Chud 08/09/23 (Wed) 15:08:06 №39602

File: 1691593686276.jpg (7.53 KB, 250x234, 1610023871956s.jpg)ImgOps

>standard battle assumptions

Chud 08/10/23 (Thu) 13:30:24 №39617

>>36722
thank you for this information

Chud 08/11/23 (Fri) 00:19:35 №39640

>>38912
no because meguka rewrote an infinite multiverse

Chud 08/14/23 (Mon) 09:35:34 №40012

File: 1692005734889.gif (46.32 KB, 639x715, 1688070839193.gif)ImgOps

>>39640
>no because meguka rewrote an infinite multiverse